“The Rail Procurement Agency, responsible for delivering the Metro West and Metro North projects, last week published its latest design update with an ‘emerging preferred route’. While this is said to be the result of a significant public consultation, it would be appear that the best route for Dublin 15 has not been chosen.
“Despite several submissions to the Rail Procurement Agency, including my own, they have chosen to ignore the needs of people living in some of the newer areas of Dublin 15. One viable alternative would have been to shift the route slightly to the West through Littllepace and back down the N3 to the Blanchardstown centre or linking up with Tyrellstown before continuing to the airport.
“Areas like Littlepace, Tyrellstown, Hartstown and Huntstown are grossly under-served by public transport at the moment. People are spending huge chunks of their daily lives commuting as a result. Metro West presents a historic opportunity to bring quality public transport to the door-steps of people in these areas. Unfortunately, this opportunity is not being grasped.
“In Clondalkin, the route has been changed so that a holy well can be preserved. I would have thought that a more fundamental route change to service under-served areas could also be seriously considered.
”It is not clear where the Metro West project lies in the Government’s list of priorities. In a reply to one of my recent parliamentary questions, the Minister for Transport confirmed that no construction activity is proposed for Metro West during 2009, but that an unspecified amount of funding will be allocated to the planning and design phase.
“The Government has not said how much funding has been allocated to the project, how much it will cost or when it is due to be completed. The first test of whether the 2015 deadline is pie-in-the-sky will be if the Railway Order application does indeed go to An Bord Pleanala is 2009 as promised. This has all the hallmarks of a project being put on an ever longer finger.
Note(1): Metro West Design Update, Rail Procurement Agency, 11th November 2008.
(Link to the Follow Document)
Metro West Design Update Nov 1th 2008.
“….crossing the River Liffey and Liffey Valley on a new bridge. The route continues on the northern bank of the Liffey Valley to Porterstown through lands at Castleknock Golf Club and Porterstown Park. The route then runs beside Porterstown Road and onto a new bridge structure at Diswellstown Road where it crosses the Royal Canal and the Maynooth Railway Line. A new stop will also be developed at Porterstown to facilitate interchange between Metro West and Iarnród Éireann Maynooth and Dunboyne services.
From the interchange stop at Porterstown the route continues to a stop at Millennium Park before turning eastwards to serve Blanchardstown Town Centre. It is intended that P&R will be provided as part of a redevelopment of adjacent lands at Blanchardstown. From the Blanchardstown Town Centre the route runs over the N3 to a stop at Tolka Valley, serving Blanchardstown Village and James Connolly Memorial Hospital before continuing northwards to run adjacent to Snugborough Road.
The route then serves the National Aquatic Centre (NAC), before reaching the junction with Ballycoolin Road from where it then turns to run eastward adjacent to the proposed upgraded road, to Ballycoolin stop. This stop will serve the Ballycollin Industrial estate and Blanchardstown Corporate Park.
The route then continues east adjacent to the Ballycoolin Road to a potential future stop at Abbottstown. From Abbottstown the route heads towards the M50 before crossing Cappagh Road to a new Cappagh stop provided to serve the industrial lands to the north of the M50, Cappagh Hospital, and residential lands to the south of the M50.
Note(2): Joan Burton’s recent parliamentary questions re: Metro West
Dáil Question
No: 201
*To ask the Minister for Transport further to Parliamentary Question No. 234 of 5 November 2008, the amount of the expenditure allocated in his 2009 Departmental budget, either as capital or current expenditure to Metro West and the DART underground; if he will to provide a detailed breakdown of this budgeted expenditure in terms of preparatory, planning and design, pre-construction, construction and support work with a time-line for the delivery of both of these infrastructure projects; when it is expected that tenders for the construction of both of these infrastructure projects will be sought; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
– Joan Burton.
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 12th November, 2008.
Ref No: 40128/08
Answered by the Minister for Transport
(Noel Dempsey)
REPLY
As I said in my reply to Parliamentary Question No. 234 of 5 November 2008, provision has been made for expenditure next year on both the DART Underground and Metro West, which will facilitate significant progress
in planning and design. No construction activity is proposed during 2009. The precise allocation for the projects will be determined in the coming weeks taking account of the out-turn of expenditure in 2008 and this remains the position.
However, I can tell the Deputy that the provision will be sufficient to allow work to continue on both projects and that Iarnród Éireann and the RPA plan to be in a position to submit applications for Railway Orders for both projects by the end of 2009. In relation to tenders, I understand that the preparation of the tender documentation will be ongoing during the Railway Order process. However, at this stage it is too early to determine a date when final tenders for construction will be sought.
As I have stated previously, the start and completion dates of Transport 21 projects which have not yet commenced will be determined by the outcome of the statutory processes and the funding allocation available during the current difficult economic climate. The provision of increased capacity will be a key priority in determining public transport investment priorities in the period ahead.
Dáil Question
No: 179_
*To ask the Minister for Transport if he will confirm the Government’s commitment to fund the development of the Metro West project; when construction of this project is due to commence; when construction of this project is due to be completed; when is it due to open; the amount it is expected to cost; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
– Joan Burton.
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 2nd July, 2008.
Ref No: 26287/08 Proof: 121
Answered by the Minister for Transport
Noel Dempsey
REPLY
The Government remains committed to the implementation of the Metro West project, which is contained in the Transport 21 strategy to transform the public transport system in the Greater Dublin Area.
The emerging preferred route for Metro West was announced by the RPA in July 2007 following an extensive consultation process on route options which included the public, residents, property owners, local authorities and other stakeholders.
A further round of consultation is now underway to provide greater definition to the route. The current phase of the consultation process will conclude in the coming weeks and the RPA will then proceed with the preparation of a Railway Order application which will be submitted to An Bord Pleanála in 2009.
I am not in a position to publish the estimated capital cost of the Metro West project in advance of the completion of the public procurement process. The publication of such commercially sensitive information prior to the completion of the competitive procurement process would prejudice the State’s capacity to derive maximum value for money in respect of the project.